Shop Now

Shop by Heat Rating

Popular Peppers

Product Categories

🌴 Peppers of Key West 5 Pack – Cayenne, Jalapeno, Habanero, Ghost & Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce Gift Set

Heat Rating : MILD

Heat Rating : HOT

Heat Rating : EXTRA HOT

$29.99

SKU: 109003
Best Selling Hot SaucesCayenneChipotleGhost (Jolokia)Gift Baskets and PacksHabaneroHeat Rating - 2Heat Rating - 3Heat Rating - 4Heat Rating - 7Hot SaucesJalapenoPeppers of Key West ProductsPeppers of Key West SaucesShop by HeatShop by Pepper TypeShop By Sauce Type
Save more when you buy more! Discount is applied at checkout. No code needed.
Buy 4-6 bottles, get 5% off
Buy 7-11 bottles, get 10% off
Buy 12+ get 15% off

🌴 Peppers of Key West 5 Pack – Cayenne, Jalapeno, Habanero, Ghost & Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce Gift Set

The Peppers of Key West 5 Pack is the ultimate hot sauce collection for spice enthusiasts, featuring five distinct heat levels and flavor profiles: Cayenne, Jalapeno, Habanero, Ghost, and Carolina Reaper. Handcrafted with premium ingredients and small-batch attention, this curated gift set delivers bold, authentic pepper flavor and a fiery experience for chili heads of all levels. Perfect for collectors, adventurous cooks, and hot sauce aficionados seeking variety and quality.

Each bottle in this five-pack provides a unique heat journey. Cayenne offers approachable, smoky heat ideal for everyday cooking, wings, and tacos. Jalapeno provides bright, fresh flavor with mild heat suitable for dips, sandwiches, and eggs. Habanero delivers fruity, medium-to-hot spice perfect for grilled meats and Caribbean-inspired dishes. Ghost Pepper ignites the taste buds with smoky, intense heat for thrill-seekers, while Carolina Reaper packs legendary extreme spice for true chiliheads looking for the ultimate challenge.

This versatile hot sauce set is perfect for marinating, glazing, dipping, and finishing dishes. Each sauce showcases premium ingredients and a carefully balanced flavor profile, ensuring both heat and taste are maximized. It’s an ideal gift for birthdays, holidays, Father’s Day, or any occasion for spice lovers who want a complete hot sauce experience in one package.

From casual home cooks to seasoned chili heads, the Peppers of Key West 5 Pack transforms meals into bold, flavorful, and fiery culinary adventures. With heat levels ranging from mild to extreme, this five-pack is a must-have for any hot sauce collection.

From mild everyday kick to extreme pepper punishment, the Peppers of Key West 5 Pack is ideal for tastings, challenges, parties, or discovering your perfect heat level.

If you’re searching for a hot sauce sampler gift, chili head gift box, pepper sauce variety pack, or extreme heat present — this five pack brings island flavor and escalating fire in every bottle.

Peppers of Key West Cayenne Hot Sauce our very own traditional Louisiana-style hot sauce. With a whopping five natural and simple ingredients, our Hot Cayenne Hot Sauce is a purist’s dream come true. Made with cayenne pepper, this sauce is packed full of flavor without atomic heat, and it’s punched up with a healthy dose of garlic.  In fact, all the texture and little white chunks in the sauce is minced garlic giving this sauce a wonderful garlic enhanced flavor.  It’s even vegan.

Our Peppers of Key West Jalapeno Garlic Sauce is our second green sauce behind our Serrano Sauce.  If you enjoy the slight tang of jalapeno peppers and the bite of vinegar, you’re going to love this sauce. Believe it or not, our sauce has only eight ingredients with the base being vinegar and jalapeno peppers.   This sauce is a testament to the flavors that both ingredients blend together.  If you are fan of jalapeno, you will love of Jalapeno Garlic Green Hot Sauce with its signature sweet and tangy taste. You can use this sauce anywhere you would normally use your favorite hot sauce, but may we suggest using it to liven up salsa Verde and any tomatillo sauce?

Peppers of Key West Habanero Hot Sauce is the second recipe we came up with.  Made with habaneros, cayenne, Worcestershire sauce, garlic, molasses, and tomato, it’s like a Bloody Mary without the olives or the vodka. Drip onto oysters and clams, drizzle onto eggs early in the morning, or dunk your favorite snack – the possibilities are endless. Sure, we’re a little bit biased when it comes to our own sauces, but our customers seem to confirm we have a winner here. The fact is, our Peppers of Key West Hot Sauces are consistently the best-selling sauces in our inventory. If people didn’t like them, we wouldn’t sell them.  If you are a fan of simple and tasty hot sauce, then give our Habanero Hot Sauce a try. We think you’ll be happy you did.

After many long hours and batches of hot sauce that were absolutely amazing but didn’t make the cut for us to put our name on, we arrived at our much-anticipated original recipe hot sauce with Ghost Peppers. Of course, there’s our Cayenne and Habanero sauces that are always fan favorites, but we’re expanding the horizons of the Peppers of Key West line of hot sauces with unique and original recipes like Goin Bananas, Rum Raisin, and now The Ghost.

Looking for a shamelessly hot sauce – try our house brand Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce. This all natural and gluten free sauce is made from diced tomatoes, onions, and a healthy dose of garlic. Powered by the Carolina Reaper Pepper, this is an extremely hot sauce with an intense and instantaneous burn. As of 2016, the reaper is the hottest pepper in the world, on average 450 times hotter than a Jalapeno. Please consume this hot sauce very carefully because it is really, really, really hot.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

❓ What’s included in the Peppers of Key West 5 Pack?
This set includes five different hot sauces made with cayenne, jalapeño, habanero, ghost pepper, and Carolina Reaper for a full range of heat levels.

❓ How spicy is this hot sauce variety pack?
It starts mild with cayenne and jalapeño, builds through habanero and ghost pepper, and finishes with extreme Carolina Reaper heat.

❓ What foods pair best with these sauces?
They’re perfect for wings, tacos, burgers, pizza, eggs, chili, ramen, BBQ, seafood, and grilled meats.

❓ Is this a good gift for hot sauce lovers?
Yes — it’s an excellent hot sauce sampler gift for birthdays, holidays, Father’s Day, and spice enthusiasts.

❓ Can beginners enjoy these 5 packs?
Absolutely. Beginners can start with cayenne and jalapeño, while experienced chili heads can jump straight to ghost and Carolina Reaper.

❓ Who should buy the Peppers of Key West 5 Pack?
Anyone who loves hot sauce samplers, chili pepper gifts, gourmet spicy food, and exploring different heat levels.

 

 

availabilityUsually Ships in 24 to 48 Hours
Save more when you buy more! Buy 3 or more bottles, get 5% off, buy 5 or more bottles get 10% off, buy 12+ get 15% off

Client Reviews

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Related Products