Call (267) 222-8029
  • Login

  • Shopping cart (0): $ 0.00
Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On TwitterVisit Us On InstagramVisit Us On Youtube

Peppers of Key West

Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Shop By Heat
    • Heat Rating: 1 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 2 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 3 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 4 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 5 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 6 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 7 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 8 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 9 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 10 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 10+
    • Close
  • Shop By Pepper
    • 7 Pot Bubblegum
    • Ancho Pepper
    • Arbol Chile
    • Banana Pepper
    • Bell Pepper
    • Birds Eye Pepper
    • Black Malabar
    • Black Pepper
    • Carolina Reaper
    • Cayenne
    • Cherry Pepper
    • Chili Pepper
    • Chipotle
    • Chocolate Habanero
    • Datil
    • Devil’s Tongue
    • Fatalii Chile
    • Ghost (Jalokia)
    • Green Amazon
    • Green Bell Pepper
    • Green Chili Pepper
    • Guajillo Pepper
    • Green Pepper
    • Habanero
    • Hatch Chili Pepper
    • Jamaican Hot Chocolate
    • Louisiana Pepper
    • Malabar Pepper
    • New Mexico Chile
    • No Pepper
    • Oleoresin Cayenne
    • Peppadew Pepper
    • Pequin Pepper
    • Peri Peri
    • Poblano Pepper
    • Red Chili Pepper
    • Red Pepper
    • Red Savina Chile
    • Scorpion
    • Serrano Pepper
    • Sriracha
    • Sweet Bell Pepper
    • Sweet Pepper
    • Tobasco Pepper
    • Tomatillo Pepper
    • Turkish Pepper
    • White Pepper
    • Yellow Bell Pepper
    • Yellow Pepper
    • Close
  • Shop By Department
    • Apparel
    • Beverages
    • Collectors Vault
    • Dry Spices
    • Extract Sauces
    • For Your Kitchen
    • Gift Baskets and Packs
    • Jelly
    • Most Popular
    • Peppers of Key West Products
    • Pepper Mills & Salt Shakers
    • Pickled Products
    • Sale Items
    • Snack Foods
    • Travel Size
    • Close
  • Shop By Sauce Type
    • Barbeque Sauces
    • Dips and Salsa
    • Fruit Based
    • Hot Sauces
    • Jerk Sauces
    • Marinades
    • Mustard
    • Sweet & Savory Sauces
    • Close
  • Awards
  • Recipes
Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Shop By Heat
    • Heat Rating: 1 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 2 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 3 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 4 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 5 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 6 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 7 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 8 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 9 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 10 of 10
    • Heat Rating: 10+
    • Close
  • Shop By Pepper
    • 7 Pot Bubblegum
    • Ancho Pepper
    • Arbol Chile
    • Banana Pepper
    • Bell Pepper
    • Birds Eye Pepper
    • Black Malabar
    • Black Pepper
    • Carolina Reaper
    • Cayenne
    • Cherry Pepper
    • Chili Pepper
    • Chipotle
    • Chocolate Habanero
    • Datil
    • Devil’s Tongue
    • Fatalii Chile
    • Ghost (Jalokia)
    • Green Amazon
    • Green Bell Pepper
    • Green Chili Pepper
    • Guajillo Pepper
    • Green Pepper
    • Habanero
    • Hatch Chili Pepper
    • Jamaican Hot Chocolate
    • Louisiana Pepper
    • Malabar Pepper
    • New Mexico Chile
    • No Pepper
    • Oleoresin Cayenne
    • Peppadew Pepper
    • Pequin Pepper
    • Peri Peri
    • Poblano Pepper
    • Red Chili Pepper
    • Red Pepper
    • Red Savina Chile
    • Scorpion
    • Serrano Pepper
    • Sriracha
    • Sweet Bell Pepper
    • Sweet Pepper
    • Tobasco Pepper
    • Tomatillo Pepper
    • Turkish Pepper
    • White Pepper
    • Yellow Bell Pepper
    • Yellow Pepper
    • Close
  • Shop By Department
    • Apparel
    • Beverages
    • Collectors Vault
    • Dry Spices
    • Extract Sauces
    • For Your Kitchen
    • Gift Baskets and Packs
    • Jelly
    • Most Popular
    • Peppers of Key West Products
    • Pepper Mills & Salt Shakers
    • Pickled Products
    • Sale Items
    • Snack Foods
    • Travel Size
    • Close
  • Shop By Sauce Type
    • Barbeque Sauces
    • Dips and Salsa
    • Fruit Based
    • Hot Sauces
    • Jerk Sauces
    • Marinades
    • Mustard
    • Sweet & Savory Sauces
    • Close
  • Awards
  • Recipes
HomeShop

Mustard

Showing 1-12 of 13 results

Sort by default sorting
  • Sort by default sorting
  • Sort by popularity
  • Sort by average rating
  • Sort by newness
  • Sort by price: low to high
  • Sort by price: high to low

Charlie’s Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce

$ 7.99

Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce

$ 8.99

Sale!

Fischer & Wieser Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard

$ 10.99 $ 9.50

Hellhound Ghost Pepper Sauce

$ 12.99

Honey-Do Honey Mustard BBQ

$ 8.99

Iguana Gold Hot Sauce

$ 6.99

Key Lime Mustard Sauce – Hot

$ 9.99

Lottie’s Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce

$ 10.99

Matouk’s Calypso Hot Sauce (Red)

$ 6.99

Matouk’s Picante Pepper Sauce (Yellow)

$ 6.99

Matouk’s West Indian Flambeau Hot Sauce (Black)

$ 6.99

Raspberry Honey Mustard

$ 10.99

  • 1
  • 2

Search Our Store

Product categories

  • Jelly (3)
  • Sale Items (20)
  • Peppers of Key West Sauces (20)
  • Peppers of Key West Apparel (5)
  • Travel Size Bottles (3)
  • Discontinued (18)
  • Peppers of Key West Products (20)
  • Shop by Pepper Type (279)
    • Datil (1)
    • Red Pepper (27)
    • Sweet Pepper (4)
    • Red Bell Pepper (7)
    • New Mexico Chile (2)
    • Ancho Pepper (3)
    • No Pepper (16)
    • Arbol Chile (1)
    • Red Chili Pepper (3)
    • Chili Pepper (11)
    • Green Pepper (1)
    • Black Pepper (23)
    • Serrano Pepper (6)
    • Hatch Chili Pepper (1)
    • Chocolate Habanero (2)
    • Fatalii Chile (1)
    • Red Savina Chile (3)
    • Pequin Pepper (1)
    • Tobasco Pepper (2)
    • Bell Pepper (7)
    • Green Bell Pepper (1)
    • White Pepper (4)
    • Oleoresin Cayenne (4)
    • Piquillo (1)
    • Caribe Chile (1)
    • Pimento Peppers (1)
    • Cayenne (58)
    • Chipotle (31)
    • Jalapeno (47)
    • Peri Peri (12)
    • Habanero (109)
    • Scotch Bonnet (17)
    • Ghost (Jolokia) (23)
    • Scorpion (12)
    • Carolina Reaper (9)
  • Blair's Hot Sauce (42)
  • Most Popular (64)
  • Collectors Vault (41)
  • Gift Baskets and Packs (10)
  • Apparel (11)
  • For Your Kitchen (20)
    • Dishware (3)
    • Pepper Mills & Salt Shakers (8)
  • Shop by Heat (341)
    • Heat Rating - 1 (32)
    • Heat Rating - 2 (50)
    • Heat Rating - 3 (60)
    • Heat Rating - 4 (42)
    • Heat Rating - 5 (37)
    • Heat Rating - 6 (19)
    • Heat Rating - 7 (30)
    • Heat Rating - 8 (21)
    • Heat Rating - 9 (7)
    • Heat Rating - 10 (12)
    • Heat Rating - 10+ (59)
  • Shop By Sauce Type (235)
    • Hot Sauces (128)
    • Extract Sauces (54)
    • Sweet & Savory Sauces (14)
    • Jerk Sauces (11)
    • Dips and Salsa (15)
    • Fruit Based (19)
    • Barbeque Sauces (24)
    • Marinades (31)
    • Mustard (13)
  • Beverages (21)
    • Bloody Mary (13)
    • Coffee (2)
  • Dry Spices (47)
  • Pickled Products (13)
  • Snack Foods (19)

About Peppers of Key West

Peppers of Key West is the best hot sauce store in the world. You are sure to find the best hot sauces, hot sauce gifts, and fun products of all things hot sauce and pepper related. We strive to ensure you, our customers, are happy.

  • Log in

  • 0 Bag
Join Our Mailing List!
We hate spam as much as you do!
Copyright 2020 © Peppers of Key West |

Website Design by Estrela Interactive