🌞🌶️ Lottie’s Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce

Bright, bold, and bursting with Caribbean flavor — Lottie’s Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce delivers vibrant yellow pepper heat with a fresh, tangy kick that instantly wakes up your taste buds.

Crafted with yellow hot peppers for a clean, fruity burn, this classic island-style sauce balances lively heat with citrusy brightness and subtle savory notes. It’s the perfect everyday hot sauce for drizzling over eggs, tacos, grilled chicken, seafood, rice bowls, and roasted veggies — or splashing into soups and marinades for extra zing.

Unlike heavy or overly vinegary sauces, Lottie’s Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce keeps the focus on pure pepper flavor. The heat hits quickly but doesn’t linger too long, making it approachable for spice lovers while still exciting enough for heat seekers.

Whether you’re cooking Caribbean-inspired dishes or simply upgrading weeknight meals, this versatile yellow pepper sauce brings sunshine and spice to every bite.

Lottie’s Traditional Barbados Yellow Hot Peppers Sauce is a scotch bonnet-based mustard sauce with both fantastic flavor and plenty of heat. Great on bratwurst, hotdogs, hamburgers, Italian sausage, or for knocking plain old barbeque sauce off its pedestal, it’ll quickly become your go-to mustard, if you can stand the burn! It rates six out of ten on our scale of hotness, and that’s no joke. Even the label states that a little goes a long way!

Here in Key West, we take pride in doing things a little differently. For instance, our cats have six or seven toes instead of the normal four or five- at least, some of them do. Don’t believe me? Next time you’re in town, just check out the Ernest Hemingway house, where you’ll find dozens of polydactyl cats roaming the grounds. So do you think we’d settle for just plain old French’s mustard? Not likely! Lottie’s Traditional Barbados Yellow Hot Peppers Sauce puts the old standbys to shame.

One of my favorite sandwiches is grilled cheese with tomato, but as the proprietor of a store with literally hundreds of hot sauces, bland is not on my menu. Enter Lottie’s Traditional Barbados Yellow Hot Peppers Sauce, just a small dollop catapults me into sandwich heaven!

Believe me, when I hear people say that Lottie’s is their favorite brand of hot sauce, I’m never surprised. It makes a great gift for that discerning foodie in your life- it’s that good.

So, if you’re looking for a mustard sauce that packs plenty of heat for a mustard, Lottie’s Traditional Barbados Yellow Hot Peppers Sauce will quickly find a place in your heart. It serves up a blazing hot tang that is not to be missed. Order up a supply right here, or better yet, visit us in person at Peppers of Key West, the hottest spot on the island!

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

🌶️ How spicy is Lottie’s Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce?
It offers a medium heat level — lively and flavorful without being overwhelming.

🌞 What does yellow pepper hot sauce taste like?
Yellow peppers provide a brighter, slightly fruitier flavor compared to red sauces, with a clean, quick heat.

🍤 What foods pair best with this sauce?
It’s fantastic on eggs, seafood, grilled chicken, tacos, rice dishes, soups, and roasted vegetables.

😋 Is this good for everyday use?
Yes! Its balanced heat and fresh flavor make it perfect for daily meals.

🥶 Should I refrigerate after opening?
Yes — refrigerate after opening to keep the flavor fresh and vibrant.