You are here: Home > Shop by Heat > Sweet and Tangy
Sweet and Tangy is the lowest of the Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce Heat Ratings. I have personally tasted all of the products we carry and rated each one to give you the most accurate Hot Sauce Heat Rating possible. Sweet and Tangy Hot Sauces will have no more than a very little amount of heat. Think about a tomato based salsa with only a dash of black pepper, that's about the Hot Sauce Heat Rating of Sweet and Tangy. The full Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce Heat Rating System is: 

Sweet and Tangy = 0 to .9
Mild = 1 to 3.9
Hot = 4 to 6.9
Extreme = 7 to 9
Weapons Grade = 9.1 to 10
Sort By:
Page of 3
Peppers of Key West Grill Pack Khatsa's Tibetan Barbeque Marinade Pineapple Coconut Mango Tequila Gourmet Sauce
Our Price: $34.99
Sale Price: $31.49
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $10.99
Sale Price: $9.89
Peppers of Key West Grill Pack Khatsa's Tibetan Barbeque Marinade Pineapple Coconut Mango Tequila Gourmet Sauce Robert Rothschild Farm
Share the love of Key West and us here at Peppers with this gift box that contains 4 of our branded Peppers of Key West grilling sauces. Khatsa's Tibetan Barbecue Marinade is a mildly spicy barbecue sauce that captures the exotic flavors of Tibet. And don't think you need to be an adventurous eater to give this one a try- it actually is among our top fifty sellers at Peppers of Key West. Pineapple Coconut Mango Tequila Gourmet Sauce from Robert Rothschild Farm is yet another example of why we love the folks on the farm. This is a truly tasty and extremely versatile sauce that will become a staple in your cupboard.
Ring of Fire Original Steak Sauce Texas Sweet & Hot Jalapenos Mango Tequila Jalapeno Grilling & Dipping Sauce
Our Price: $11.99
Sale Price: $10.79
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Ring of Fire Original Steak Sauce Texas Sweet & Hot Jalapenos Mango Tequila Jalapeno Grilling & Dipping Sauce Earth and Vine
Ring of Fire Original Steak Sauce is a Johnny Cash reference, NOT a heat-level reference! Good for so much more than just steak, the (very gentle) kick comes from black pepper and chipotle, and it's sweetened with fig concentrate and molasses. Texas Sweet & Hot Jalapenos are pickles for chiliheads. They're not pickles, but they are pickled jalapenos that are sweet just like a bread and butter pickle is. They are perfect right out of the jar for sandwiches, burger, tuna, or chicken. Mango Tequila Jalapeno Grilling & Dipping Sauce from Earth and Vine Provisions is the perfect sauce for those of you who look for sauces that are all about flavor and not so much about the burn from heavy duty peppers.
Robert Rothschild Farm Blackberry Chipotle Sauce Raspberry Wasabi Gourmet Dipping Mustard Hot Pepper Raspberry Chipotle Sauce
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Robert Rothschild Farm Blackberry Chipotle Sauce Raspberry Wasabi Gourmet Dipping Mustard Hot Pepper Raspberry Chipotle Sauce Robert Rothschild Farm
Robert Rothschild Farm Blackberry Chipotle Sauce continues the Rothschild tradition of making the best berry sauces in the world. With this very mild sauce, they combine the sweetness of blackberry with chipotle for an ever so slight pepper heat. Robert Rothschild Farm really has a winner with Raspberry Wasabi Dipping mustard. Its elegant yet unexpected blend of flavors hooks you from the first bite. Hot Pepper Raspberry Chipotle Sauce by Robert Rothschild Farm is a sweet and smoky finishing sauce and glaze you'll find yourself reaching for with surprising frequency. Let your creativity out of the bag with this gourmet sauce, it'll surprise you.
Cherry Pomegranate Habanero Sauce Hot Plum Chipotle Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $10.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Cherry Pomegranate Habanero Sauce Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Plum Chipotle Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard
Cherry Pomegranate Habanero Sauce has a soothing, sweet taste with just a hint of heat on the back end. The smooth blend of tart from the cherries and the sweet from the pomegranate will take your next meatball dish to a different dimension. With Hot Plum Chipotle Grilling & Glazing sauce by Spice Exchange, you get sweetness from ripe, succulent plums and smokiness from chipotle peppers. Don't let the chipotle scare you, though! Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard from Fischer & Wieser is a game changer in the world of mustard sauce. Mustard is a natural complement to vinegar, brown sugar, and white wine, and the addition of tangy ginger to this pungent mix is a stroke of genius.
Robert Rothschild Farm Ginger Wasabi Sauce Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce Robert Rothschild Farm Green Chile Pepper Dip
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Robert Rothschild Farm Ginger Wasabi Sauce Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce Robert Rothschild Farm Green Chile Pepper Dip
Ginger Wasabi Sauce by Robert Rothschild Farm is a sauce that will bring your Asian-inspired dishes to life. You don't have to be a master chef to cook like one, as long as you have this delicious gourmet sauce on hand. Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce, otherwise known as "Harvest Apple Cider Glaze" is a must have in your grilling sauce arsenal. This is the ideal sauce for coating pork, ribs, and hams while grilling them to perfection. This delicious mix of cream cheese, green chiles, jalapeno peppers, onions, and crushed red peppers will never let you down when you want a quick spread or a savory party food.
Fischer and Wieser Papaya Lime Serrano Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze Robert Rothschild Farm Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Fischer and Wieser Papaya Lime Serrano Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze Robert Rothschild Farm Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip
Papaya Lime Serrano Sauce from Fischer & Wieser combines one of the best fruit flavor combinations of all time: papaya and limes. They've added the one thing in the world that could possibly improve this combination: hot peppers. Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze is one of my favorite products, and a best seller at Peppers of Key West. This is a boutique, hand crafted product that is lovingly made one jar at a time. Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip has nothing whatsoever to do with Onion Blossoms. But as you might expect, Onion Blossom Horseradish Dip has everything to do with horseradish.
Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub Key Lime Mustard Sauce King Neptune's Fish Seasoning
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub Key Lime Mustard Sauce King Neptune's Fish Seasoning
Sometimes the best tasting products begin in someone's back yard, and Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub by The Culinary Connection is a prime example. Infused with the flavors of brown sugar, garlic, and onions, this is a sweet addition to your hot and smoky grilling arsenal. Key Lime Mustard Sauce by Floribbean captures the tangy taste of Key West, and Peppers is at the ready to deliver it straight to your door! This creamy, mild sauce features 100% pure key lime juice and mustard seeds. King Neptune's Fish Seasoning by The Culinary Connection is your answer to flavorful, succulent fish dishes in no time- but it's not just for the fruits of the sea! This versatile seasoning uses garlic, onion, lemon salt, and dill to complement just about any dish you can dream up!
Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Spice Fischer and Wieser Roasted Blueberry Chipotle Sauce Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub - 4oz
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Spice Fischer and Wieser Roasted Blueberry Chipotle Sauce Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub - 4oz
Chili Pepper Republic's Key Lime Spice is a mild yet flavorful and unique mix of spices that will give your food the fresh taste of Key West, whether you're here on the island or as far away as Alaska! Roasted Blueberry Chipotle Sauce by Fischer & Wieser is one of those sauces you might never have dreamed up in a thousand years,but once you taste it, it's a dream come true! Roasted Blueberry Chipotle Sauce is stuffed to the brim with fresh blueberries. Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub is another fine creation from Chef Buck Naked who is just a bit further up the Key's in Key Largo. Chef Buck masterfully blends 33 gourmet ingredients including a variety of dried peppers.
Maker's Mark Bourbon Flavored Gourmet Sauce Fischer and Wieser Pomegranate & Mango Chipotle Sauce Garlic Peppercorn Seasoning
Our Price: $12.99
Sale Price: $11.69
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Maker's Mark Bourbon Flavored Gourmet Sauce Fischer and Wieser Pomegranate & Mango Chipotle Sauce Garlic Peppercorn Seasoning
Maker's Mark Bourbon Flavored Gourmet Sauce is a winner of every major tasting competition. Maker's Mark is America's original premium bourbon whisky crafted by 7th generation Kentucky distillers in Loretto, KY. Pomegranate & Mango Chipotle Sauce by Fisher & Wieser is a fruity, mildly hot blend of mango, pomegranate, garlic, and jalapeno and chipotle peppers. At Peppers of Key West, we love to get creative with hot sauce and this is a great one for that. Garlic Peppercorn Seasoning is a classic combination of cracked pepper, minced garlic, mustard seed, and sea salt for beef filets, pork loin, lamb and chicken. Designed with pepper lovers in mind.
Honey Barbeque Smoked Beef Jerky - 8 oz Honey Barbeque Smoked Beef - 4 oz Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub - 10 oz
Our Price: $15.99
Sale Price: $14.39
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $13.99
Sale Price: $12.59
Honey Barbeque Smoked Beef Jerky - 8 oz Honey Barbeque Smoked Beef - 4 oz Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub - 10 oz
We've gone out and searched the ends of the earth - well, the continental US - for the best jerky we could find! This is it, made by Up North Jerky Outlet, the jerky comes in four different heat levels. We've gone out and searched the ends of the earth - well, the continental US - for the best jerky we could find! This is it, made by Up North Jerky Outlet, the jerky comes in four different heat levels. Chef Buck Naked's Hog Rub is another fine creation from Chef Buck Naked who is just a bit further up the Key's in Key Largo. Chef Buck masterfully blends 33 gourmet ingredients including a variety of dried peppers.