You are here: Home > Shop by Type > Mustard
Mustard, the red headed stepchild of the sauce world. So many people think its just for hot dogs, but oh no- its for so much more. It's not just a condiment you know. Mustard is a sauce all it's own and it's also an ingredient in some of the worlds best hot sauces. Take a look at the Peppers of Key West selection and you'll probably be surprised. Give mustard a chance, won't you?
Sort By:
Page of 2
Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce Matouk's Calypso Hot Sauce Branford's Hot Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $3.60
Our Price: $6.99
Sale Price: $6.29
Our Price: $6.99
Sale Price: $6.29
Robert Rothschild Farm Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce Matouk's Calypso Hot Sauce
Robert Rothschild Farm Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce inspires Indian masterpieces at home. Madras Curry is traditionally more sweet than savory and deeply red in color. The red color is not a function of the curry itself, but .the other spices added. Matouk's Calypso Hot Sauce brings the fiery heat of the West Indies, specifically Trinibad and Tobago. It's chock full of scotch bonnet peppers in a sweet and spicy mustard base. Unlike other spicy mustard, Matouk's Calypso Hot Sauce has a pepper heat. The flavor is in the bottle! This sauce has a hot spicy zest and is an excellent seasoning that is great for steak, chicken wings, and grilled food with a degree of heat that anyone can handle.
IL Primo Jalapeno Mustard Raspberry Wasabi Gourmet Dipping Mustard Robert Rothschild Farm Ginger Wasabi Sauce
Our Price: $6.99
Sale Price: $6.29
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
IL Primo Jalapeno Mustard Raspberry Wasabi Gourmet Dipping Mustard Robert Rothschild Farm Ginger Wasabi Sauce
Robert Rothschild Farm really has a winner with Raspberry Wasabi Dipping mustard. Its elegant yet unexpected blend of flavors hooks you from the first bite. Ginger Wasabi Sauce by Robert Rothschild Farm is a sauce that will bring your Asian-inspired dishes to life. You don't have to be a master chef to cook like one, as long as you have this delicious gourmet sauce on hand.
Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce Buhba's Butt Blaster X-Hot Sauce Charlie's Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce Buhba's Butt Blaster X-Hot Sauce Charlie's Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce
With a name like Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce, it’s gotta be good, right? Trust me on this one, boys and girls, Colon Cleaner Hot Sauce will cure what ails ‘ya, alright. It’s made from scotch bonnet peppers and rated at about the middle of our heat index. Buhba's is a South Carolina style extreme hot sauce. Add it to your favorite mustard barbecue sauce and bring a little "Butt Blasting" heat to your ribs and chicken. Charlie at Sauce Crafters has really outdone himself this time with Charlie's Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce.
Spicy Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip Mad Dog 357 Extreme Mustard Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Spicy Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip Mad Dog 357 Extreme Mustard Sauce
Spicy Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard by Galena Canning Company is going to knock your socks off! You_re gonna want to chuck your run of the mill honey mustard sauce straight into the trash with the first bite of this spicy, sassy brew! Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip is another gourmet winner from Robert Rothschild Farm. Raspberry vinegar imparts the raspberry flavor to ground mustard and honey and that's about it! Mad Dog 357 Extreme Mustard Sauce, like all things Mad Dog, is extremely hot. This molten gold Extreme Mustard is light-years beyond a condiment or spread - it's a golden bullet that blasts incredibly scrumptious heat and flavor onto everything.
Habby Habanero's Tropical Heat Hot Sauce Baron West Indian Hot Sauce Lee's Sweet Hot Mustard
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Habby Habanero's Tropical Heat Hot Sauce Baron West Indian Hot Sauce Lee's Sweet Hot Mustard
Habby Habanero's Tropical Heat Hot Sauce is the more mild and sweeter younger brother to Habby's Slap Your Momma Hot Sauce and is more mustard than Slap Your Momma Hot Sauce. Tropical Heat Hot Sauce is sweetened with peaches and heated by habanero. Baron West Indian Hot Sauce hails from the island of St. Lucia and is a masterful combination of mustard, onion, garlic, vinegar, and Scotch Bonnet peppers. This is a sweeter mustard sauce and has a hefty kick from the Scotch Bonnets to boot. Lee's Sweet Hot Mustard is not quite as dangerous as its big brother (Lee's Sweet Insane Mustard),but it still cuts right to the point. The heat comes from jalapenos and cayenne peppers and it's rounded out with the sweetness of sugar.
Lee's Sweet Insane Mustard Robert Rothschild Farm Tarragon Peppercorn Mustard Lee's Sweet Spicy Mustard
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $7.19
Lee's Sweet Insane Mustard Robert Rothschild Farm Tarragon Peppercorn Mustard
Lee's Sweet Insane Mustard is a winner at the Fiery Food Challenge and is a bonefide crowd-pleaser. If you don't believe us, just try just a dollop of this multi-pepper (habanero, cayenne, jalapeno) mustard over baked chicken or set it out as a dipping sauce. Robert Rothschild Farm Tarragon Peppercorn Mustard is a savory combination of mustard, peppercorns, and tarragon- a treat for mustard lovers the world around. Robert Rothschild Farm is known for their high quality, unique, and extremely tasty products. Sweet and Spicy all at the same time - Lee makes a really good line of mustards for your enjoyment.
Key Lime Mustard Sauce - Hot Guyank Sweet Hot Pepper Sauce Pete's Heat Professional Strength Hot Sauce
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Key Lime Mustard Sauce - Hot Guyank Sweet Hot Pepper Sauce Pete's Heat Professional Strength Hot Sauce
Key Lime Mustard Sauce - Hot is the hotter sibling (pun intended) to Floribbean Key Lime Honey Mustard Sauce. Even with the "hot" in the name, don't shy away from this mustard in fear of heat, it's a very mild heat, but is hot compared to the original version. Guyank Sweet Hot Pepper Sauce has an interesting story behind it. The word Guyank is a mash up of Guyana and Yankee. The people behind the name are a married couple, the wife from Guyana and the husband from the Northeast US. The sauce is indeed sweet and hot. This Pete's Heat Professional Strength Hot Sauce is an ingenious, mouth-watering blend of ingredients that lends some sweet to your savory dishes. Ever thought of adding pineapple, papaya, honey, and lime to a mustard-based hot sauce.
Key Lime Mustard Sauce Mad Anthony's Fiery Mustard Sauce Island Grove Key Lime Honey Mustard
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Key Lime Mustard Sauce Mad Anthony's Fiery Mustard Sauce Island Grove Key Lime Honey Mustard
Key Lime Mustard Sauce by Floribbean captures the tangy taste of Key West, and Peppers is at the ready to deliver it straight to your door! This creamy, mild sauce features 100% pure key lime juice and mustard seeds. Michael Anthony sure is multi-talented! Besides being the bassist for Van Halen, Mr. Anthony lends his name to a line of hot sauces. This one, also known as his Fiery Mustard Sauce, is affectionately called "hot lava in a bottle." Island Grove Key Lime Honey Mustard is the standard for stone crab dipping sauces down here. Almost all of the restaurants on the island serve this or create their own version. Simply made with mayonnaise, mustard, honey, and horseradish.
Black Peppered Jalapeno Mustard Blair's Heat Wasabi Green Tea Exotic Hot Sauce Pain is Good Batch #164 Honey Cayenne Mustard
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $8.09
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Black Peppered Jalapeno Mustard Blair's Heat Wasabi Green Tea Exotic Hot Sauce Pain is Good Batch #164 Honey Cayenne Mustard
Black Peppered Jalapeno Mustard from Third Coast Gourmet is a slightly sweet, savory yet bold blend that will set aside any ordinary mustard. This isn't a really hot mustard, but it is full of flavor and has an ever so slight kick from the peppers. Blair's Heat Wasabi Green Tea Exotic Hot Sauce is the most mild of all of Blair's sauces. That doesn't mean it lacks a punch of flavor though. In fact, Wasabi Green Tea Hot Sauce might be one of the most unique hot sauces you ever try. If you know the "Pain is Good" products you will also know all their labels have people with sour looking grimaces on their faces. As lighthearted as that is, these sauces have tons of flavor. Batch #112 is their hot honey mustard sauce.
Pain is Good Batch # 66 Jalapeno Wasabi Hot Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard Molten Golden South Carolina Hot Pepper Sauce
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $10.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Sale Price: $8.99
Pain is Good Batch # 66  Jalapeno Wasabi Hot Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard Molten Golden South Carolina Hot Pepper Sauce
Pain is Good Batch # 66  Jalapeno Wasabi Hot Sauce is a very unique hot sauce that will expand your horizons and clear your nasal passages. As the name implies, this hot sauce is made with jalapeno and wasabi, an amazing combination. Sweet, Sour & Smokey Mustard from Fischer & Wieser is a game changer in the world of mustard sauce. Mustard is a natural complement to vinegar, brown sugar, and white wine, and the addition of tangy ginger to this pungent mix is a stroke of genius. Good things often come out of nowhere, and so it was with Molten Golden South Carolina Hot Pepper Sauce. Mark and Julie received an excess of pepper plants as a gift, and once the plants matured, they had a whole lot of chili pepper plants.