You are here: Home > Shop by Heat > Mild
Mild is the second step of the Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce Heat Ratings. I have personally tasted all of the products we carry and rated each one to give you the most accurate Hot Sauce Heat Rating possible. Mild Sauce ratings are from 1 to 3.9. Sauces closer to 1 will be very mild, just a touch of heat. Sauces closer to 3.9 will have a bit of a bite, but nothing that will send you running to the fridge for a gallon of milk. The full Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce Heat Rating System is: 

Sweet and Tangy = 0 to .9
Mild = 1 to 3.9
Hot = 4 to 6.9
Extreme = 7 to 9
Weapons Grade = 9.1 to 10
Sort By:
Page of 9
Atomic Fireballs (Jawbreakers) Arizona Gunslinger Hot Popcorn Peter Piper Mini
Our Price: $0.25
Sale Price: $0.23
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Atomic Fireballs (Jawbreakers) Arizona Gunslinger Hot Popcorn Peter Piper Mini
If you have any gullible friends, this is the candy for you! Tell your buddy it's a jawbreaker, and watch his jaw drop when the heat kicks in!! Great for nostalgic chilieheads, or anyone with a sweet tooth! Arizona Gunslinger Hot Popcorn is microwave popcorn with a kick that could only come from Arizona Gunslinger. The addition of chili peppers to this movie night staple lets you stay true to your chilihead nature while snacking. Take your favorite sauce with you everywhere you go. This 1.6 oz. plastic bottle is the perfect size for the sauce fanatic on the go. Also a great item for promo's, gift baskets and when you just need that little something extra on your gift package.
Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz Chipotle Habanero Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz Classic Recipe Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz - Chilies & Peppers
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz  Chipotle Habanero Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz  Classic Recipe Demitris Bloody Mary Seasoning 2oz - Chilies & Peppers
Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe is one of the best mixes available to get the restaurant style, professional-quality Bloody Mary you crave. When you find the ultimate Bloody Mary mix, you never let it go. While Peppers of Key West has many options to choose from, Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe could be The One! Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe is one of the best mixes available to get the restaurant style, professional-quality Bloody Mary you crave. When you find the ultimate Bloody Mary mix, you never let it go. While Peppers of Key West has many options to choose from, Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe could be The One! Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe is one of the best mixes available to get the restaurant style, professional-quality Bloody Mary you crave. When you find the ultimate Bloody Mary mix, you never let it go. While Peppers of Key West has many options to choose from, Demitri's Bloody Mary Classic Recipe could be The One!
Blair's Death Rain Potato Chips - Chipotle Ass Kickin Habanero Popcorn Ring of Fire Beef Jerky
Our Price: $1.99
Sale Price: $1.79
Our Price: $2.99
Sale Price: $2.69
Our Price: $2.99
Sale Price: $2.69
Blair's Death Rain Potato Chips - Chipotle Ass Kickin Habanero Popcorn Ring of Fire Beef Jerky
Blair's Death Rain Potato Chips follow in the deep and smoking footsteps of Blair's line of hot sauces and extracts. Everyone who knows hot sauce, knows Blair and his devilish concoctions. His version of potato chips is no exception. Ass Kickin Habanero Popcorn lives up to its name. Habanero chili powder does its ass kickin duty atop handfuls and handfuls of popped corn glory. The makers of the world famous Ring of Fire hot sauces have expanded their line to now include Ring of Fire Beef Jerky - a healthy treat that combines the great garlic, herb and habanero flavors you love with U.S.D.A Grade A beef
Marie Sharp's Mini Mild Habanero Pepper Sauce Spicy Gourmet Peanut Brittle Louisiana Swamp Scum Hot Sauce
Our Price: $2.99
Sale Price: $2.69
Our Price: $8.99
Sale Price: $3.59
Our Price: $4.00
Sale Price: $3.60
Marie Sharp's Mini Mild Habanero Pepper Sauce Spicy Gourmet Peanut Brittle Louisiana Swamp Scum Hot Sauce
A milder version of the famous sauce line from Belize. Marie Sharp's Habanero Pepper Sauces is the finest product of its kind. This unique carrot-based blend achieves the perfect balance between flavor and heat. A mini bottle is the perfect size. Who doesn't love peanut brittle? Okay, sure, folks with peanut allergies, but who else? I admit it, I have a sweet tooth. Rather, I have a mouthful of sweet teeth. This delicious little snack brings together two of my favorite things: peanut brittle and peppers. Louisiana Swamp Scum Hot Sauce is a delicious, smokey, award winning hot sauce. This sauce is new take on an old favorite, Louisiana style hot sauce, with a sweeter taste and finer texture.
Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce El Yucateco Chipotle Hot Sauce El Yucateco Green Habanero Hot Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $3.60
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Robert Rothschild Farm Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce El Yucateco Chipotle Hot Sauce El Yucateco Green Habanero Hot Sauce
Robert Rothschild Farm Zesty Madras Curry Simmer Sauce inspires Indian masterpieces at home. Madras Curry is traditionally more sweet than savory and deeply red in color. The red color is not a function of the curry itself, but .the other spices added. El Yucateco Chipotle Hot Sauce is a classic sauce from the Yucatan of Mexico and uses chipotle pepper as the heat and spice. Based in red tomatoes with select spices and seasonings, El Yucateco Chipotle Hot Sauce delivers a smooth consistency and flavor. El Yucateco Green Habanero Hot Sauce hails from Merida, Yucatan, Mexico and is is the hotter of the two original El Yucateco sauces.  This special blend of ingredients gives a fresh, home-cooked flavor to your Mexican meals.
Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #1 Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #2 Island Grove Caribbean Essence
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #1 Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #2 Island Grove Caribbean Essence
Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #1 is a our very own original recipe traditional Louisiana-style hot sauce. With a whopping five natural and simple ingredients, our Hot Sauce #1 is a purist's dream come true. Peppers of Key West Hot Sauce #2 is the second recipe we came up with (hence the name - get it?), and our hottest to date. Made with habaneros, cayenne, Worcestershire sauce, garlic, molasses, and tomato. It's a sauce made for prime time. Island Grove Caribbean Essence is a tropical blend of spicy seasoning made with fresh key lime and habanero pepper. The folks at Island Grove have really come through in creating an authentic Caribbean spice mix.
El Yucateco Chile Habanero Hot Sauce Damn Good Sweet & Spicy Beef Jerky Damn Good Hot and Spicy Beef Jerky
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $4.49
El Yucateco Chile Habanero Hot Sauce Damn Good Sweet & Spicy Beef Jerky Damn Good Hot and Spicy Beef Jerky
El Yucateco Chile Habanero Hot Sauce is classic sauce from the Yucatan of Mexico and now comes in an 8oz bottle for even longer enjoyment. Constructed using the El Yucateco classic recipe based in Habanero chilies and red tomatoes with fine spices and select seasonings. Damn Good Beef Jerky is all natural with no preservatives. The Sweet and Spicy version has a start that is indeed a bit sweet, then follows through with a nice kick to the end. It's not hellaciously hot, but there is definitely a little heat. Damn Good Hot and Spicy Beef Jerky is the hotter sibling of Damn Good Sweet and Spicy, but is still all natural and without preservatives. If you are a fan of beef jerky, you'll be sad if you don't give this a try, especially if you like spicy jerky.
Amazon Green Hot Sauce Arizona Gunslinger Jalapeno Sauce Cholula Chili Garlic Hot Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Amazon Green Hot Sauce Arizona Gunslinger Jalapeno Sauce Cholula Chili Garlic Hot Sauce
Amazon Green Hot Sauce has become one of the most popular products we carry. There's good reason for that. Produced in the deep recesses of the Amazon jungle, or more specifically, Cartagena, Columbia, Amazon Green Hot Sauce is a very basic sauce for you purists. Arizona Gunslinger Jalapeno Sauce is the little brother of Arizona Gunslinger Habanero Pepper Sauce. The ingredients are the same, minus the habanero peppers, so it still gives you the great flavor and simplicity without as much heat. Cholula Chili Garlic Hot Sauce is quickly becoming as popular as that brand whose name we do not speak (starts with a "T"). Cholula is a great table sauce and can be found in restaurants across the country and there's good reason for that.
Caribbean Condiment Sauce Marinade Charlie's Hard Times Hot Sauce Cholula Original Hot Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Caribbean Condiment Sauce Marinade Charlie's Hard Times Hot Sauce Cholula Original Hot Sauce
Caribbean Condiment Sauce Marinade is a cool, calm sauce and is very unique in that it has a base of cucumbers with a light curry flavor. Coming from Costa Rica, Caribbean Condiment is a great addition to spice up any dish, especially summery fare. It may not be particularly adventures, especially when compared with many of the other offerings to be found at Peppers of Key West, but this is a good, honest hot sauce. Cholula Original Hot Sauce is quickly becoming as popular as Tabasco brand hot sauces, Cholula is a great table sauce and can be found in restaurants across the country. Cholula has an unmatched flavor that goes great on anything.
Hog's Breath Red Hot Sauce Liquid Summer Datil Hot Sauce Salsa De Chile Chipotle Chile Pepper Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Our Price: $5.99
Sale Price: $5.39
Hog's Breath Red Hot Sauce Liquid Summer Datil Hot Sauce Salsa De Chile Chipotle Chile Pepper Sauce
Hog's Breath Red Hot Sauce by the world famous Hog's Breath Saloon in sunny Key West this is their mid-range heat offering. With a base of vinegar and cayenne pepper, it's perfect for those who love traditional Louisiana-style hot sauce. Liquid Summer Datil Pepper Hot Sauce is made by Sauce Boss Bill Wharton. The Datil pepper is grown in St. Augustine, Florida, where they hold an annual Datil Pepper Festival. I'm telling you, they are serious about this pepper up in St. Augustine! Salsa De Chile Chipotle Chile Pepper Sauce brings you the authentic flavor of southwestern cuisine with this chipotle based hot sauce. Chipotle peppers are actually jalapeno peppers that are dried and smoked, so jalapeno lovers typically love chipotle too.