You are here: Home > Fruit Based
Not all hot sauces are red. Not all hot sauces have tomatoes. Peppers of Key West has compiled a selection of fruit-based sauces for every occasion. You'll find hot and spicy Apple-based sauce, fiery blueberries, and sweet raspberries–and everything in between. Our fruit-based hot sauces  are some of our best sellers because even the most seasoned hot sauce lovers often find something they've never tried before and then they just can't get enough.
Sort By:
Page of 3
Nellie & Joe's Old Sour Marinade Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice (Plastic Bottle) Nellie & Joe's Key Lime Juice (Glass Bottle)
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $3.99
Our Price: $4.99
Our Price: $5.99
Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice (Plastic Bottle) Nellie & Joe's Key Lime Juice (Glass Bottle)
An island tradition. Specialized for marinating seafood, meat, & poultry. Also enhances soups, chowders, & salads! Nellie & Joe's began operation in 1968 and has grown to become the preferred supplier of Key Lime juice in the country. Now you, too, can experience the authentic sweet-tart taste of paradise without leaving your own kitchen. This Juice always remind you of the flavor and beauty of Old Town Key West, with its tart freshness and the label's depiction of our  quaint style of houses you'll find lining every street here in Old Town.
Nellie & Joe's Mango Key Lime Juice Hot N' Heavy Peach Sauce Dichicko's Lemon & Herb Peri-Peri Hot Sauce
Our Price: $5.99
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $6.39
Our Price: $6.99
Nellie & Joe's Mango Key Lime Juice Hot N' Heavy Peach Sauce
Nellie & Joe's Mango Key Lime Juice is a different take on Nellie and Joe's Famous Key Lime Juice. It's of the same high quality and authentic flavor, but has the addition of sweet and tropical mango. Hot & Heavy Peach Sauce is a unique take on grilling that falls somewhere between barbeque sauce and baby food. *Insert joke here, right?* Really, though, the only similarity to baby food is the freshly pureed peaches that make up the base of this sauce - from there, the tomatoes, garlic, molasses, and habaneros take over, with a pinch of black pepper for good measure. Hot & Heavy is one of our favorites for grilled pork chops - the heat from the grill carmelizes the sugars in the peaches, which set off a chain reaction in the tomatoes, culminating in your tongue doing a little jig of happiness and satisfaction. Hot & Heavy Peach Sauce is a knockout on baked salmon and a stellar alternative to the same old humdrum meatloaf, too! This Hot Sauce is the true testament that it is possible to use a Hot Sauce for more than just heat. The perfect heat level is only one aspect of the perfectly balanced flavor which is rich in fresh Ingredients as well as Herbs & Spices. Add a Tbsp. of this to any Chili, Soup or Cheese Dip for that something special everyone will be talking about.
Peppers of Key West is Goin' Bananas Hot Sauce The Original Key West Key Lime Juice Peppers of Key West Key Lime Dessert Cream Cheese Mix
Our Price: $6.99
Our Price: $6.99
Our Price: $6.99
The Original Key West Key Lime Juice Peppers of Key West Key Lime Dessert Cream Cheese Mix
Have you ever tasted a hot sauce with bananas in it? Just like Key West itself, this sauce is sweet with a little bit of heat. Fresh, ripe bananas supply the main flavor, with honey, raisins, tamarinds, Chipotle peppers, and just a touch of habanero for good measure, making Goin' Bananas the perfect compliment to any pork dish. Our favorite use: about halfway through grilling thick cut pork chops (when they're good & sizzlin'), add a bit of this on and let it caramelize just a touch. As a gourmet flourish, top your chops with some sauteed onions before serving - you'll be the envy of the neighborhood! The Original Key West Lime Juice has pretty simple ingredients—the pure, all natural juice of fresh key limes with no additives and no preservatives. There is no heat, because as I said there are no added ingredients, and that includes hot peppers. Peppers of Key West Key Lime Dessert Cream Cheese Mix has the sweet-tart tang of key limes and diced dried jalapenos to remind you of the sun and fun of Key West. We love unique products and our proud to offer this as one of the most unique we carry.
Peppers of Key West Raspberry Jalapeno Dessert Cream Cheese Mix El Chipotle Balsamic Blackberry Hot Sauce El Chipotle Picante Pumpkin Hot Sauce
Our Price: $6.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Peppers of Key West Raspberry Jalapeno Dessert Cream Cheese Mix
Peppers of Key West Raspberry Jalapeno Dessert Cream Cheese Mix is a new classic combination of sweet raspberries and diced dried jalapenos. One of the newest trends to hit mainstream in the hot sauce world is fruit based hot sauces. Made with plump, juicy blackberries, blazin' Chipotle chilies, and aged balsamic vinegar, this smoky sweet hot sauce is great for grilled pork and chicken. Use it over cream cheese with gingersnap cookies. Try is on ice cream and pancakes too! For all you fans of gourds out there (yes yes, we know...), we present a unique and tasty sauce by El Chipotle called Picante Pumpkin. A bit of cumin and cinnamon compliment the pureed pumpkin base and chipotle smokiness to perfection, making this not quite sweet, but not too savory flavored sauce the natural go-to for spicing up everything from pumpkin pie to sweet potatoes to butternut squash soup to the stuffing for your next turkey! Whisk some up with a bit of honey and glaze that bird, too! Picante Pumpkin brings the taste of an autumn harvest to any meal!
The Green Parrot Hot Mango Mama Jump Up and Kiss Me Passion Fruit Hot Sauce Key West Key Lime Hot Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Dave's Gourmet Jump Up and Kiss Me Passion Fruit Hot Sauce
This hot mama will add sweet spice to your fish, shrimp, chicken, ham, pork, or steak! She's sassy and irresistible on the grill. You won't be able to get enough! Jump Up and Kiss Me Passion Fruit Hot Sauce will make you want to jump up and get more food to put it on. Blended with habanero, pineapple, and honey this sauce is a sweet and only slightly hot delight. Key West Key Lime Hot Sauce has a definite feel of the southwest to it with Serrano, Ancho, and New Mexican chilies, and the tart flavorings of Key Lime Juice and Lime Zest.
Raspberry Wasabi Gourmet Dipping Mustard Blind Betty Blind in the Rind Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Spice
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Blind Betty Blind in the Rind Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Spice
Robert Rothschild Farm really has a winner with Raspberry Wasabi Dipping mustard. Its elegant yet unexpected blend of flavors hooks you from the first bite. Blind Betty's Blind in the Rind hot sauce is a perfect blend of sweet and mild heat. And we at Peppers of Key West are not the only ones who think so. Blind in the Rind is the second of Betty's sauces to win a Scovie award! Chili Pepper Republic's Key Lime Spice is a mild yet flavorful and unique mix of spices that will give your food the fresh taste of Key West, whether you're here on the island or as far away as Alaska!
Spicy Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserves
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserves
Spicy Raspberry Habanero Honey Mustard by Galena Canning Company is going to knock your socks off! You_re gonna want to chuck your run of the mill honey mustard sauce straight into the trash with the first bite of this spicy, sassy brew! Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip is another gourmet winner from Robert Rothschild Farm. Raspberry vinegar imparts the raspberry flavor to ground mustard and honey. Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Raspberry Preserves is a sweet and spicy combination that reminds us why Robert Rothschild Farm is as successful as they are. The sweet taste of Raspberries coupled with a little spice from hot peppers creates a unique and delicious flavor.
Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Jerk Seasoning Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Mango Guava Magic Chili Pepper Republic Sweet Orange Habanero Spice
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Key Lime Jerk Seasoning Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Mango Guava Magic Chili Pepper Republic Sweet Orange Habanero Spice
Chili Pepper Republic Key Lime Jerk Seasoning is a Key West style twist on traditional jerk seasoning.  If you love jerk style seasoning and cooking, you'll love slightly lighter take on it. Chili Pepper Republic Caribbean Mango Guava Magic has the flavor you've been looking for. There's a very good reason they call it "Magic" and you'll know why the fist time you add this dry spice to your favorite meat. Chili Pepper Republic Sweet Orange Habanero Spice is a sweet and spicy dry seasoning that transports you to a paradise of culinary pleasures. This carefully crafted mix blends orange oils, chili peppers, and sugar to create an unforgettable flavor.
Catch a Fire Mango Chutney Catch a Fire Mango Pineapple Chutney Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Peach Preserves
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Catch a Fire Mango Chutney Catch a Fire Mango Pineapple Chutney Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Peach Preserves
Catch a Fire Mango Chutney is an authentic Jamaican chutney and has a very distinctive flavor. Visitors to Peppers of Key West often ask what the difference is between a chutney and a salsa. It's actually a pretty simple answer. Catch a Fire Mango Pineapple Chutney is a more complex take on Catch a Fire Mango Chutney with the addition of pineapple. Just like it's sibling, it packs a fair amount of heat, but won't leave you calling 911. Robert Rothschild Farm Hot Pepper Peach Preserves creates a symbiotic mixture of peaches, orange peel, and sugar. The folks at Rothschild Farm then add in a pinch of Red Chili Pepper to spice things up and round out the sweetness of the fruits and sugar.
Robert Rothschild Farm Peach Coconut Mango Habanero Seafood Sauce Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Hot Sauce Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Extra Hot Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Robert Rothschild Farm's Peach Coconut Mango Habanero Seafood Sauce Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Hot Sauce Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Extra Hot Sauce
Robert Rothschild Farm creates a sweet full bodied sauce with complex flavors and a versatile array of applications in their Peach Coconut Mango Habanero Seafood Sauce. As with all of their products, this one is a Peppers of Key West fan favorite. Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Hot Sauce is apple sauce, right? How could it be hot? Well, it is! It's also a very tasty sauce with a very unique flavor. The folks at Rising Sun Pepper Farm don't play around with mixing bland ingredients. Rising Sun Apple Cinnamon Chipotle Extra Hot Sauce is apple sauce, right? How could it be hot? Well, it is! It's also a very tasty sauce with a very unique flavor. The folks at Rising Sun Pepper Farm don't play around with mixing bland ingredients.