You are here: Home > BBQ
Barbecue sauces come in all flavors.  Some BBQ sauces are hot and spicy, some are fruity and sweet, others still are chock full of mustard or molasses. Just like with hot sauce, your particular taste in barbecue sauce is as unique as you are. Peppers of Key West has a large selection of BBQ sauces that span from sweet to down right hot.  If you have a particular taste, don't limit yourself to sauces labeled as "barbecue sauce."  Almost any sauce can be used to heat up the flavor of whatever you put on your grill.
Sort By:
Page of 2
Nellie & Joe's Old Sour Marinade Hot N' Heavy Peach Sauce Blair's Death Rain BBQ
Our Price: $4.99
Sale Price: $3.99
Our Price: $7.99
Sale Price: $6.39
Our Price: $6.99
Hot N' Heavy Peach Sauce Blair's Death Rain BBQ
An island tradition. Specialized for marinating seafood, meat, & poultry. Also enhances soups, chowders, & salads! Hot & Heavy Peach Sauce is a unique take on grilling that falls somewhere between barbeque sauce and baby food. *Insert joke here, right?* Really, though, the only similarity to baby food is the freshly pureed peaches that make up the base of this sauce - from there, the tomatoes, garlic, molasses, and habaneros take over, with a pinch of black pepper for good measure. Hot & Heavy is one of our favorites for grilled pork chops - the heat from the grill carmelizes the sugars in the peaches, which set off a chain reaction in the tomatoes, culminating in your tongue doing a little jig of happiness and satisfaction. Hot & Heavy Peach Sauce is a knockout on baked salmon and a stellar alternative to the same old humdrum meatloaf, too! Blair’s Death Rain BBQ won’t drown out the essence of your food. It will flood it with flavor with the rich savory spice mix of fresh ground Habanero Chilies, Sugar, Salt, Paprika, Garlic, Onion, and Natural Smoke Flavor.
Khan's Island Habanero Hot Sauce Hog's Ass Barbeque Charlie's Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Hog's Ass Barbeque
Gourmet Habanero Hot Sauce by Khan's Island Sauce is made from a family recipe that originated in Trinidad and Tobago This is a good, solid, basic barbecue sauce that has it all. It has just the right amount of sweetness, and the mild level of heat isn't going to put off even your most chili-shy guests. Charlie at Sauce Crafters has really outdone himself this time with Charlie's Hard Times Honey Mustard Barbeque Sauce.
Chef Buck Naked's Reef Rub - 4 oz Old Dixie Southern Style BBQ Hot Sauce Chef Buck Naked's BBQ Spice - 4 oz
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $7.99
Chef Buck Naked's Reef Rub - 4 oz Old Dixie Southern Style BBQ Hot Sauce Chef Buck Naked's BBQ Spice 4 oz
Chef Buck Naked Reef Rub has a pretty bodacious mix of flavors and spices to help you rock your next meal. Sugar, salt, onion powder, garlic powder, coriander, rosemary, marjoram, ginger, dill, celery seed, powdered vinegar, and lemon flavor. Old Dixie Southern Style BBQ Hot Sauce blends vinegar, yellow mustard, brown sugar, garlic, onions, and cayenne peppers with ketchup to get the authentic, bone suckin' flavor you crave. Chef Buck Naked's BBQ Spice blend will "Thrill Your Grill" and make anything you add it to taste like it was created by a certified grill master. It's not just great on any meat, but it will also add a BBQ blast to your baked beans, potatoes, and veggies.
Mad Dog Inferno Hot Sauce Peppers of Key West Asian Marinade Peppers of Key West Chicken Wing Sauce
Our Price: $7.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Peppers of Key West Asian Marinade Peppers of Key West Chicken Wing Sauce
If you're looking to take your relationship with barbeque sauce to the next level, this sauce will do the trick! Molasses is the second ingredient, and as such this is an elegantly sweet sauce; vinegar, molasses, garlic, onion, jalapeno peppers, clove, herbs, spices - sounds just like BBQ, doesn't it? Oh, did we mention that the third ingredient is pepper extract?! Use sparingly! Peppers of Key West Asian Marinade uses low sodium soy and is a best selling sauce. Use Asian Marinade for fish, meat, or poultry on the grill or in the kitchen. Asian Marinade makes a great dressing too. Packed full of fresh bleu cheese and garlic, this Peppers of Key West original is everything that you associate with wings except the chicken itself. Most people dip their wings in bleu cheese anyway, so why not a sauce with it in it already!
Pappy's XXX White Lightnin Barbecue Sauce Tibetan Barbeque Marinade Tibetan Fire Sauce
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Pappy's XXX White Lightnin Barbecue Sauce
Pappy's XXX White Lightning Barbecue Sauce gives a sweet robust flavor with a hint of hickory. The slight sweetness and tang of Pappy's XXX White Lightnin Barbecue Sauce tastes fabulous on pulled pork, baby back ribs, and of course chicken. Khatsa's Tibetan Barbecue Marinade is a mildly spicy barbecue sauce that captures the exotic flavors of Tibet. This slightly sweet, slightly spicy, slightly nutty barbecue sauce has a hint of chocolate. Made with ginger, caraway and garlic, it's excellent on everything from meats & fish to tofu. We can't keep enough of this sauce in the store! The award winning sauces from Khatsa are based on Tibetan recipes. 7% of the profits from their products are committed to nature preservation projects in Tibet.
Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon Brand Barbeque Sauce Mango Tequila Jalapeno Grilling & Dipping Sauce Red Ghost Honey BBQ Ghost Wings
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon Brand Barbeque Sauce
Fighting Cock Kentucky Bourbon Brand Barbeque Sauce is a bourbon based BBQ sauce that has just the right amount of kick behind a rich smokey bourbon flavor. The smoke is achieved by including real hickory smoke to the tomato and vinegar mixture. For those of you who prefer the flavor to the burn, welcome to heaven! This tropical sauce aligns the sweetness of fresh mango, the tang of cilantro, and the flavor of jalapenos with a splash of tequila for a sauce with universal appeal! This is our staff favorite for fish tacos, and we love it as a salad dressing, but it is a perfect compliment to grilled chicken and white rice, as well as being the secret ingredient in phenomenal fruit salsa! Made with the jolokia pepper, or "ghost pepper" as it is sometimes called, this wing sauce is a perfect choice when you want the flavor of jolokias, but not the colon spasm that comes with them!
Bourbon Q Barrel Select Kentucky Bourbon Barbecue Sauce Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub Bone Suckin Sauce - Hot
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Bourbon Q Barrel Select Kentucky Bourbon Barbecue Sauce Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub Bone Suckin Sauce - Hot
Bourbon Q Barrel Select Kentucky Bourbon Barbecue Sauce is in a class by itself thanks to the addition of Kentucky bourbon to a recipe that is equal parts sweet, smoky, and tangy. Sometimes the best tasting products begin in someone's back yard, and Steve's Back Yard BBQ Rub by The Culinary Connection is a prime example. Infused with the flavors of brown sugar, garlic, and onions, this is a sweet addition to your hot and smoky grilling arsenal. Bone Suckin Sauce (Hot) is the hotter version of the original Bone Suckin Sauce and is one heck of a lip-smackin, head-shakin barbecue sauce. Winner of numerous awards including an "A+" from Health Magazine and first place winner in the Battle of the Sauces.
Bone Suckin Sauce Uncle Jimi's Almost World Famous Key Lime and Chipotle Barbeque Sauce Mountain Man Chipotle BBQ Sauce
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Bone Suckin Sauce Uncle Jimi's Almost World Famous Key Lime and Chipotle Barbeque Sauce Mountain Man Chipotle BBQ Sauce
Bone Suckin Sauce (Original) is one heck of a lip-smackin, head-shakin barbecue sauce. Winner of numerous awards including an "A+" from Health Magazine and first place winner in the Battle of the Sauces. Uncle Jimmy's Almost World Famous Key Lime Chipotle BBQ marries the tartness of key limes to the smokiness of the chipotle pepper for an all-purpose sauce that tastes heavenly. The thick, stick-to-your-ribs texture makes this an ideal choice for grilling. Mountain Man Chipotle BBQ Sauce isn't your mother's BBQ sauce- unless you live deep in the Appalachian mountains. As soon as you open this bottle, you'll want to go out and hunt down some meat to slather it on.
Papaya Chipotle Pineapple Sauce Peppers of Key West Jerk Sauce Lottie's Yellow Hot Pepper Sauce
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $8.99
Our Price: $9.99
Papaya and Pineapple dance together in this wonderfully flavored smooth grilling sauce that bursts with tropical flavor and a smoky & subtle south-of-the-border heat. Papaya Chipotle Pineapple Sauce can be basted on grilled chicken, pork or seafood. Deck out shrimp cocktails, or blend with couscous, pineapple, shrimp and cashews for a fast and fantastic meal. Heck, just toss some with avocado and baby greens, add grilled salmon or tuna, and wrap in a tortilla for healthy light meal on the go! Unlike it's spicier cousin the Jamaican jerk sauce, which is liable to catch up with you after dinner in the form of heartburn, or the next morning in the form of... (!) Well, anyway, our Key West-style jerk marinade is sweetened with mango and raisins and seasoned with nutmeg and allspice, for a mild but tasty flavor that everyone can enjoy. If it grows together, it goes together, making this the perfect marinade for chicken, fish, pork, or shrimp! Lottie's Traditional Barbados Yellow Hot Peppers Sauce is a scotch bonnet-based mustard sauce with both fantastic flavor and plenty of heat. Great on bratwurst, hotdogs, hamburgers, Italian sausage, or for knocking plain old barbeque sauce off its pedestal.
Hot Plum Chipotle Sauce Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze
Our Price: $9.99
Our Price: $9.99
Our Price: $9.99
Hot Plum Chipotle Sauce Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce Fischer and Wieser Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze
With Hot Plum Chipotle Grilling & Glazing sauce by Spice Exchange, you get sweetness from ripe, succulent plums and smokiness from chipotle peppers. Don't let the chipotle scare you, though! Fischer and Wieser Harvest Apple Cider Grilling Sauce, otherwise known as "Harvest Apple Cider Glaze" is a must have in your grilling sauce arsenal. Sweet & Savory Onion Glaze is one of my favorite products, and a best seller at Peppers of Key West. This is a boutique, hand crafted product that is lovingly made one jar at a time.